How to tackle an accidental HIPAA violation

How to Tackle an Accidental HIPAA Violation

The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) establishes federal guidelines for managing medical records and protected health information (PHI). Understanding how HIPAA compliance impacts healthcare practices is essential to avoid HIPAA violations and ensure the privacy of patient data. Given the volume of sensitive patient information, healthcare providers must maintain stringent safeguards to protect patient privacy.

Despite best efforts, unintentional HIPAA violations occur, often due to human error or accidental disclosures. This guide will help covered entities and business associates differentiate between types of HIPAA violations, understand the consequences, and take appropriate action to prevent and respond to them.

What is an accidental HIPAA violation?

Despite strict HIPAA regulations, healthcare providers may still experience accidental HIPAA violations. These occur when an unintentional disclosure of protected health information (PHI) without proper authorization occurs. Even with safeguards, covered entities or healthcare employees can unintentionally violate HIPAA rules, leading to unauthorized access to sensitive patient information.

Common examples of unintentional HIPAA violation include:

• Accidentally viewing the wrong patient records
• Sending emails or paper records to the wrong recipient
• Losing devices that store protected health information

These HIPAA violations affect patients by compromising their patient privacy and security. Although these violations are often accidental, healthcare organizations are still responsible for the breach, which could result in fines or civil penalties.

To avoid accidentally violating HIPAA, healthcare professionals must regularly update their compliance protocols and ensure all staff are trained to safeguard PHI. This proactive approach minimizes the risk of accidental breaches and ensures that covered entities follow proper procedures to protect patient data by HIPAA regulations.

Incidental HIPAA violations vs accidental HIPAA violations

Incidental HIPAA violations occur when PHI is inadvertently disclosed despite having proper safeguards. Unlike accidental HIPAA violations, incidental disclosures are sometimes unavoidable and may not need to be reported if HIPAA rules were followed.

Under the HIPAA Privacy Rule, incidental disclosures are allowed if the covered entity or business associate has implemented appropriate safeguards and adhered to the "minimum necessary" standard. For instance, a covered entity might inadvertently disclose a patient's name during a public conversation, but it may not require reporting if privacy measures were in place. (U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, 2022)

Healthcare organizations must differentiate between unintentional HIPAA violations and incidental disclosures to improve compliance strategies.

How should practitioners respond to accidental HIPAA violations?

Though no one wants to face a HIPAA violation, healthcare providers must know how to respond effectively when it occurs. Immediate action can minimize the impact of unintentional HIPAA violations. The primary steps include investigating, performing a risk assessment, and implementing necessary training to prevent future breaches.

Investigating the HIPAA violation

Upon discovering an accidental disclosure of protected health information (PHI), the healthcare employee must report the incident to the designated HIPAA privacy officer. The privacy officer will then initiate an internal investigation to understand the nature of the violation.

Key elements considered during the investigation include the type of sensitive patient information involved, who received the unauthorized disclosure, and whether the exposed data is likely to be re-disclosed. Understanding these factors helps determine if the violation warrants further action or reporting.

Conducting a risk assessment

A thorough risk assessment is essential to gauge the severity of the HIPAA violation. The covered entity will evaluate factors such as the nature of the breach, the type of patient data compromised, and the likelihood of patient harm. This step also examines whether proper safeguards were in place to prevent the breach and how the organization can address the common HIPAA violations that occurred.

In some cases, if a staff member acted in good faith or immediately rectified the mistake, the breach may not require formal reporting to the Office for Civil Rights.

Implementing corrective measures

After evaluating the incident, covered entities and business associates must decide whether the violation requires procedure changes or additional staff training. This could include revising privacy and security rules, training new staff, or updating software to protect PHI better. Moreover, the business associate agreement stipulates that any accidental breach must be reported to the covered entity within 60 days.

Addressing these issues promptly ensures that healthcare organizations can avoid future unintentional HIPAA violations.

By understanding how to respond to unintentional HIPAA violations, healthcare providers can mitigate the consequences of violating HIPAA regulations and protect patient privacy and the practice from further risk.

What are some examples of unintentional HIPAA violations?

Understanding examples of common unintentional HIPAA violations can help healthcare providers avoid them. Some scenarios include:

• A physician accidentally views a patient's medical records without authorization and immediately exits the system.
• A healthcare worker discusses a patient's treatment within earshot of others, inadvertently disclosing sensitive patient information.
• A physician stores PHI on an unencrypted USB drive that is later stolen, constituting a breach under HIPAA's privacy and security rules.
• A business associate processes patient data without a proper business associate agreement, which violates HIPAA regulations.

These examples show how unintentional HIPAA violations can still result in severe consequences for covered entities if HIPAA compliance protocols are not followed.

Common FAQs around HIPAA violations

The most common HIPAA violations can be complex due to constantly evolving HIPAA regulations and the frequent introduction of new protocols. To help clarify these issues, we've compiled a list of frequently asked questions addressing some of the most common HIPAA compliance concerns.

When will an accidental HIPAA violation be reported to the Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights? 

If PHI is unauthorized disclosed, an accidental HIPAA violation must be reported to the OCR. For breaches affecting fewer than 500 individuals, the report must be submitted within 60 days following the end of the calendar year when the breach was discovered.

What is the burden of proof in the breach notification rule? 

The covered entity or business associate has the burden of proof to show that an unauthorized disclosure does not constitute a breach that requires notification.

Can a HIPAA violation lead to termination?

Yes, intentional HIPAA violations may result in termination. However, the outcome of unintentional violations depends on the employer and the severity of the breach.

How can healthcare providers avoid common HIPAA violations?

Healthcare providers can avoid common HIPAA violations by ensuring strict adherence to HIPAA regulations, maintaining up-to-date privacy and security rules, and providing ongoing staff training on safeguarding PHI and preventing accidental HIPAA violations.

What steps should be taken if someone inadvertently violates HIPAA?

If you accidentally violate HIPAA, immediately report the incident to your HIPAA privacy officer. They will initiate a risk assessment and determine the necessary steps, including whether a breach notification is required. Prompt reporting helps mitigate the impact of the violation.

Final thoughts

Maintaining HIPAA compliance is crucial for healthcare providers to protect protected health information and avoid the consequences of accidental HIPAA violations. Despite best efforts, unintentional HIPAA violations can still occur due to human error or inadequate safeguards. These violations, whether related to medical records, patient data, or unauthorized disclosures, can have severe repercussions for covered entities and business associates.

To ensure compliance with HIPAA regulations and prevent common HIPAA violations, healthcare organizations should implement strong privacy and security rules, conduct regular risk assessments, and maintain clear business associate agreements. Utilizing healthcare compliance software can help covered entities and healthcare employees safeguard PHI, monitor access to patient records, and prevent accidental disclosures.

Compliance tools, like Carepatron, provide valuable support by enforcing proper authorization, securing sensitive data, and ensuring adherence to Breach Notification Rules and other HIPAA guidelines. This proactive approach helps healthcare providers protect patient privacy, reduce HIPAA complaints, and maintain patient trust while avoiding civil penalties or criminal liability associated with HIPAA violations.

Reference

U.S. Department of Health & Human Services. (2022, October 19). Summary of the HIPAA privacy rule. www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/index.html.

‍