End of Life Care Ethical Issues

What is end-of-life care?

End-of-life care is a comprehensive approach to supporting individuals who are nearing death. It includes a range of medical, emotional, and spiritual interventions aimed at ensuring the highest quality of life possible during the final stages of a terminal illness. This type of care prioritizes comfort and dignity, addressing symptoms such as pain, breathing difficulties, and digestive issues while also providing emotional and psychological support to patients and their families.

A significant aspect of end-of-life care is palliative care, which focuses on alleviating the symptoms and stress of serious illness rather than attempting to cure the underlying disease. This care involves detailed advance care planning to honor the patient's wishes regarding life-sustaining treatments, such as mechanical ventilation or resuscitation. By adhering to basic ethical principles, end-of-life care ensures that patients receive compassionate and respectful treatment that aligns with their values and preferences during their final days (National Institute on Aging, 2022).

Kinds of support end-of-life care provides

End-of-life care provides various types of support to terminally ill patients to ensure their comfort, dignity, and quality of life. This care encompasses physical, emotional, spiritual, and practical support, guided by basic ethical principles and aimed at both patients and their families.

Physical comfort

Physical comfort is a crucial aspect of end-of-life care, focusing on alleviating pain and managing symptoms to ensure the patient's comfort and dignity. Here's what that entails:

• Pain management: For terminally ill patients, pain management is crucial. Palliative medicine focuses on alleviating severe pain through medications like morphine, ensuring the patient's life is as comfortable as possible without concerns about long-term drug dependency.
• Breathing difficulties: Shortness of breath, a common issue, can be managed by raising the head of the bed, using a fan, or administering medications. These interventions aim to ease the discomfort associated with breathing problems.
• Skincare: Skin irritation and bedsores can significantly impact a patient's quality of life. Keeping the skin clean and moisturized and regularly changing the patient’s position can prevent these issues.
• Digestive issues: Nausea, vomiting, constipation, and loss of appetite are managed through medications and dietary adjustments. Encouraging small, frequent meals can help, but it's essential not to force food, respecting the patient's natural decline in appetite.
• Temperature regulation: Monitoring and adjusting the room temperature, along with providing appropriate clothing and blankets, can address the patient's sensitivity to temperature changes, enhancing their comfort.

Emotional, mental, and spiritual support

Providing emotional, mental, and spiritual support is essential in addressing the psychological and spiritual needs of patients and their families, promoting peace and well-being during the end-of-life journey.

• Counseling and therapy: Emotional and psychological support is vital for both patients and their families. Counseling and support groups help in coping with the emotional strain of terminal illness.
• Communication: Open and compassionate communication helps address the fears and concerns of patients, promoting emotional well-being and allowing them to express their wishes and needs.

• Spiritual Care: Spiritual support helps patients find peace and meaning as they approach the end of their lives. This can involve religious rituals, spiritual counseling, or simply respecting their beliefs and values.

Practical support

Practical support focuses on assisting with daily tasks and ensuring that the patient's wishes regarding medical interventions are respected, thereby maintaining their autonomy and dignity. Let's go into more detail:

• Advance care planning: This involves discussing and documenting the patient’s preferences for life-sustaining treatments and other medical interventions. It ensures that their wishes are respected, enhancing their autonomy and dignity.
• Practical assistance: Assisting with daily tasks, such as bathing, dressing, and using the bathroom, helps maintain the patient’s comfort and dignity. Providing tools like bedside commodes or shower stools can make these tasks easier.

Goals of end-of-life care

End-of-life care has several essential goals aimed at ensuring that terminally ill patients receive compassionate, respectful, and dignified care during their final days. These goals focus on alleviating suffering, enhancing quality of life, and supporting patients and their families. Here are its goals:

• Alleviating pain and managing symptoms: One primary goal of end-of-life care is alleviating pain and managing symptoms effectively. This involves using palliative medicine to control severe pain, breathing difficulties, nausea, and other distressing symptoms.
• Enhancing quality of life: End-of-life care prioritizes the quality of life for terminally ill patients. This means providing care that focuses on comfort and dignity rather than attempting to cure the illness.
• Respecting patient autonomy and wishes: Another crucial goal is respecting the patient's autonomy and wishes. This is achieved through advance care planning, where patients can express their preferences regarding life-sustaining treatments and other medical interventions.
• Providing emotional and spiritual support: End-of-life care also aims to provide comprehensive emotional and spiritual support to patients and their families. This includes counseling, support groups, and spiritual care to help them cope with the emotional strain of terminal illness.
• Offering practical assistance: Finally, end-of-life care includes offering practical assistance with daily tasks and ensuring the patient's environment is as comfortable as possible.

By focusing on these goals, end-of-life care seeks to provide a compassionate, respectful, and dignified experience for terminally ill patients, supporting them and their families through one of life's most challenging phases (National Institute on Aging, 2022).

Examples of common End-of-Life Care Ethical Issues and dilemmas

End-of-life care often involves complex ethical dilemmas that healthcare providers and family members must navigate. These dilemmas arise from respecting patient autonomy, ensuring the best possible care, and minimizing suffering. Medical ethics principles, such as beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice guide decision-making processes, but real-life scenarios often present challenging conflicts and uncertainties. Additionally, legal aspects can add another layer of complexity, as healthcare providers must ensure their actions comply with legal standards while respecting the wishes of dying patients.

Here are some examples:

Withholding and withdrawing treatment

One of end-of-life care's most challenging ethical dilemmas is deciding when to withhold or withdraw life-sustaining treatment. Healthcare providers must balance respecting patient autonomy with the obligation to do no harm. In cases where continuing treatment may cause more suffering without significant benefits, it is ethical to consider stopping such interventions. Discussions with patients and family members are crucial to ensure everyone understands the reasons behind these decisions and that they align with the patient's wishes and best interests (Thorns, 2020).

Truth-telling and prognosis disclosure

Honesty in communicating prognosis is essential for respecting patient autonomy. However, it can be challenging to determine how much information a dying patient wants to know, especially as they approach the end of life. Healthcare providers must be skilled in delivering this information sensitively, ensuring that the patient fully understands their condition while respecting their wishes if they prefer not to know all the details. Effective communication can help patients and families make informed decisions about their care.

Advance care planning

Advance care planning involves discussing and documenting patients' preferences for end-of-life care, including their desires for medical interventions. This planning ensures that healthcare providers and family members honor the patient's wishes, especially if they cannot communicate. Ethical dilemmas can arise when there is a conflict between the patient's documented wishes and the perspectives of family members or healthcare providers. Ensuring clarity and thorough documentation can help mitigate these conflicts.

Pain and symptom management

Managing pain and other distressing symptoms is a primary goal of end-of-life care, yet it presents ethical challenges, especially regarding the use of opioids and sedatives. Healthcare providers must balance effective pain relief with concerns about potential life-shortening effects. The principle of double effect, which justifies actions that have both good and bad effects, is often applied here. The intention should always be to alleviate suffering, not to hasten death, and this distinction must be communicated clearly to all involved.

Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)

Decisions about attempting CPR on critically ill patients, particularly those in the intensive care unit, are ethically complex. CPR is often unlikely to be successful in terminally ill patients and may lead to a diminished quality of life if successful. Healthcare providers must discuss the patient's prognosis and potential outcomes with them and their families, ensuring informed decisions about whether to attempt CPR are made. Clear documentation of these decisions is vital to avoid unnecessary distress.

Use of sedation at the end of life

Sedation can be necessary to relieve severe agitation and distress in dying patients. However, it raises ethical questions about potentially hastening death. The doctrine of double effect applies here, justifying sedation when the primary intention is to relieve suffering, even if it may inadvertently shorten life. Healthcare providers must carefully consider each case, ensuring that sedation is used appropriately and the patient's and family's concerns are addressed.

Clinically assisted nutrition and hydration

Deciding when to withdraw clinically assisted nutrition and hydration involves complex ethical considerations. While essential for life, these interventions can become burdensome and offer no benefit in the final stages of life. Healthcare providers must weigh the benefits and burdens of continuing such treatments and discuss these considerations with patients and their families. Ethical and legal guidelines provide a framework for making these difficult decisions.

Legal aspects of end-of-life care

Legal aspects play a significant role in end-of-life care, ensuring ethical decisions align with the law. Healthcare providers must carefully navigate issues such as the legality of withholding treatment, patient consent, and advance directives. Understanding and adhering to legal requirements helps protect the rights of dying patients and ensures that healthcare providers act within their professional and legal boundaries.

Ethical principles that end-of-life care nurses must uphold

In end-of-life care, nurses navigate complex ethical dilemmas guided by these principles:

Autonomy

Autonomy is a cornerstone of end-of-life care, honoring patients' right to self-determination. Individuals should have their healthcare decisions respected, even when they are incapacitated. Advance directives (ADs) are crucial here, offering instructions for future medical care. These directives, such as living wills and health care proxies, ensure patients' wishes are upheld, empowering them to make decisions aligned with their values and beliefs (Akdeniz et al., 2021).

Beneficence

In the journal of Akdeniz et al. (2021), beneficence obliges healthcare providers to seek the most beneficial interventions for their patients, particularly in end-of-life scenarios where patients' wishes might not be explicitly stated. Physicians often collaborate with patients, their families, or proxies to determine the best course of action. This collaborative approach ensures that patients receive care that is aligned with their values and preferences, fostering trust and enhancing the quality of end-of-life care.

Nonmaleficence

Nonmaleficence underscores the importance of avoiding harm to patients, even in the pursuit of beneficial interventions. While some medical interventions may cause discomfort, their benefits should outweigh the potential harm. According to Akdeniz et al. (2021), healthcare professionals must carefully assess the risks and benefits of treatments, ensuring that interventions align with patients' best interests and minimize unnecessary suffering.

Justice

Justice emphasizes fair and equitable distribution of healthcare resources, particularly relevant in end-of-life care where limited resources may influence decision-making. Healthcare providers are ethically obligated to advocate for fair treatment, ensuring that all patients receive appropriate care regardless of socioeconomic status or other factors. By promoting fairness and equity, healthcare professionals uphold the integrity of end-of-life care practices and mitigate disparities in access to quality care (Akdeniz et al., 2021).

Consequences of violating end-end-of-life care ethical principles

Violating end-of-life care ethical principles can have significant consequences, as illustrated in the case study of Mr. Green's suicide attempt, documented in the article "The patient suicide attempt – An ethical dilemma case study" by Jie (2015).

Patient trust and confidentiality breach:

When nursing staff withhold crucial information about a patient's suicidal thoughts, it can erode trust between the patient and healthcare providers. In Mr. Green's case, if the nurse had kept his suicide attempt a secret, it would have violated his trust and compromised his confidentiality, potentially leading to a breakdown in the therapeutic relationship between Mr. Green and the healthcare team. This breach of trust may make Mr. Green feel abandoned or betrayed, affecting his willingness to engage in further care or disclose important information about his condition.

Suboptimal care and treatment planning

Failing to disclose Mr. Green's suicide attempt to other healthcare professionals can hinder the development of a comprehensive care plan tailored to his needs. Without a full understanding of his mental health status and risk factors for self-harm, healthcare providers may overlook crucial interventions or treatments, potentially exacerbating Mr. Green's distress and compromising his overall well-being. In this case, sharing information about Mr. Green's suicide attempt enabled the nursing team to identify contributing factors, provide appropriate interventions, and collaborate effectively with other healthcare professionals to optimize his care and ensure a peaceful end-of-life experience (Jie, 2015).

Ethical and legal ramifications

Neglecting to disclose critical information related to a patient's safety, such as suicidal ideation, can have legal and ethical implications for healthcare providers and institutions. By prioritizing patient confidentiality over patient safety, healthcare professionals may inadvertently violate ethical principles such as beneficence and nonmaleficence, emphasizing the obligation to act in the patient's best interests and avoid causing harm. In Mr. Green's case, adherence to ethical guidelines and protocols, along with effective communication and collaboration among healthcare team members, facilitated appropriate risk assessment, intervention, and follow-up care, ultimately leading to a positive outcome for the patient and his family.

Why use Carepatron as your nursing software?

Carepatron is a leading nursing software that offers a comprehensive suite of features designed to meet the complex needs of healthcare professionals. It focuses on enhancing patient care and streamlining administrative tasks, making it the premier solution in the healthcare industry.

Carepatron offers advanced functionality, such as electronic health records system, care planning, and documentation, which enable nurses to efficiently track patient progress, manage medications, and coordinate multidisciplinary care teams. It also incorporates healthcare compliance software, ensuring compliance with ever-changing regulations and standards.

The platform's user-friendly interface and customizable workflows make it an ideal solution for healthcare professionals working in diverse settings, including those specializing in organ or system failure and mechanical circulatory support nurses. It offers flexibility and scalability to adapt to various care environments.

Carepatron's commitment to innovation and continuous improvement sets it apart as the preferred choice for nursing software. With a dedicated team focused on enhancing the platform's capabilities and incorporating user feedback, Carepatron ensures healthcare professionals have access to cutting-edge tools and technologies, including support for advanced medical therapy.

Schedule a demo or sign up for a free trial to see how Carepatron can elevate your nursing workflow and enhance patient outcomes. Join the Carepatron community and revolutionize your nursing practice now!

References

Akdeniz, M., Yardımcı, B., & Kavukcu, E. (2021). Ethical considerations at the end-of-life care. SAGE Open Medicine, 9(9). https://doi.org/10.1177/20503121211000918

Jie, L. (2015). The patient suicide attempt – An ethical dilemma case study. International Journal of Nursing Sciences, 2(4), 408–413. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijnss.2015.01.013

National Institute on Aging. (2022). Providing care and comfort at the end of life.. https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/end-life/providing-care-and-comfort-end-life

Thorns, A. (2020). Ethical and legal issues in end-of-life care. Clinical Medicine, 10(3), 282–285. https://doi.org/10.7861/clinmedicine.10-3-282